Team Edgar or Team Nathaniel?

I personally would choose Edgar. His style is more mysterious and eerie which brings a greater interest to me.  Also, since Edgar had so much death and hard times in his life he could greatly relate between what he wrote and his real life.  Yes, Nathaniel does relate his real life to his stories but I feel it is more prominent with Edgar because he uses such strong words and description.  Overall, the creepiness of Edgar's writings are more interesting and appealing to me.